Fence Replacement Cost Breakdown: What to Expect and How to Save

Replacing a fence is a can be a significant investment, but it doesn’t have to break the bank. Our Customers upgrade for a variety of reasons including for privacy, aesthetics, but most often our customers replace fences because their old fence is old and falling over. When making an investment in your property it is good to understand what makes up the final installed price. Below, we’ll discuss what contributes to the cost of fence replacement, ways to save, and the benefits of hiring a professional versus DIY.

What Contributes to the Cost of a Fence Replacement?

1. Materials
   • Wood: This is the most traditional residential fence material used because of its timeless look and its affordability. Wood fencing can be made with a variety of types of wood but the most common and durable in the Sacramento, CA area are redwood or cedar. The type of wood used will impact the price of the fence project by +/- 15%, but what really will increase the cost of materials on a fence project is when you select a more elaborate style that requires more materials.
   • Vinyl: Vinyl privacy fences or front picket style fences are easily available and cost effective. Each brand will vary in price by +/- 20%. The lowest price will be found the color white, but if you switch to another color like tan or wood tone expect the price to increase by approximately 20%. Even with the more expensive upfront cost, based on the durability and low-maintenance makes this material a fantastic and lower cost fence material.
   • Metal (e.g., wrought iron or steel): Wrought iron and steel fences are known for their strength and majestic style. All metal fence options come with a higher material cost. In addition , metal fences often come with higher material and installation costs.
   • Chain-Link: Is one of the most durable and affordable fence styles, however it offers a more commercial aesthetic look to it. It is commonly used for large areas, commercial buildings, industrial yards, and rustic areas.
2. Labor
   Labor typically accounts for about 65% of the total cost. Experienced contractors can complete projects efficiently, but factors like uneven terrain, rocky ground, or other obstacles can increase the time required and, therefore, the expense.
3. Length and Height and Style
   Larger projects or taller fences mean more materials and time for assembly increasing the finished cost of the fence installation. Additionally, the more detailed the styles of fence will increase the materials and labor costs as well. Installing a more traditional style and height of fence like a 6-foot-tall dog ear redwood fence, will greatly lower the cost of your fence replacement.
4. Site Preparation
   Removing an old fence, clearing debris, or addressing landscaping obstacles will add to labor charges. One way you can save money is to do the cleanup of the work area yourself ahead of the installation day. This allows the installation crews to work more efficiently and save you money.

How to Save Money on Fence Installation

1. Get Multiple Quotes
   Obtain quotes from several reputable contractors to compare prices, warranties, and workmanship. It is important to ensure that their proposals are apples to apples the same to be able to compare them equally.
2. Be Selective About Materials
   Choose a fence material and style that fits both your needs and your budget. Opting for a more affordable style doesn’t mean sacrificing quality.
3. Work With a Trusted Contractor
   Choose a fence replacement contractor with a proven track record have experienced teams capable of completing projects promptly and with exceptional quality.
4. Plan for Long-Term Maintenance
   While wood fences may have a lower initial cost, they often require more upkeep. Materials like vinyl or metal may be a have a larger upfront cost, but they can save money over time.
5. Prepare the Area Yourself
   Save on labor costs by clearing the work area of obstacles, debris, or old fencing before the installation team arrives.
6. Collaborate With Neighbors
   If the fence will divide properties, consider splitting costs with your neighbor for a mutually beneficial solution.

DIY vs. Hiring a Professional

For those considering a DIY approach, it’s important to weigh the pros and cons.

DIY Pros:

• Potential cost savings on labor
• Full control over the project timeline

DIY Cons:

• Lack of expertise may lead to mistakes, costing time and material waste.
• Time Spent- What is your time worth? These projects always take longer than expected for a DIY’er and you have to take your time into account.
• Requires purchasing or renting tools like post hole diggers, saws, and nailers.

Why Hire a Professional?

Hiring licensed fence experts ensures:

• Fast, efficient installation by skilled crews.
• Access to professional-grade tools and materials.
• A warranty for peace of mind.
• Compliance with local regulations and permits.
• The assurance of a durable, level, and sturdy fence that lasts for years.

Final Thoughts: Invest Wisely in Your Fence

Replacing a fence is an opportunity to enhance your property’s value, functionality, and curb appeal. By understanding the cost breakdown and implementing smart savings strategies, you can maximize your budget. Whether you’re tackling a project solo or working with professionals, proper planning ensures the result will meet your expectations and last for years to come.